Let’s put izzi and P1 Wimax aside, because I need a wireless broadband service that covers beyond the Klang Valley area. So I have only 2 options- MAXIS or CELCOM.

I have been using CELCOM Broadband @ 384 kbps for nearly 2 years since July 2007. Although I am not satisfied with its speed of service (usually maximum at 20kbps) but at least it still able to let me send and receive email or browse Internet in the major cities like PJ, Subang, Genting, Penang, Ipoh, Malacca, Johor Baru and Cherating (Kuantan Pahang).

Why CELCOM Wireless Broadband?

I am now getting an additional wireless broadband service for my family member and I have decided to subscribe the same service- CELCOM Wireless Broadband 384kbps @ RM68/month package (without USB modem stick, with Vodafone USB modem stick is RM89/month), here is why:

1. Price: MAXIS wireless broadband’s subscription fee is more expensive than CELCOM
   MAXIS: RM118/month (with Maxis postpaid, otherwise RM138) <> CELCOM: RM68/month
2. Coverage
   I had tested CELCOM’s wireless broadband coverage at the areas that my family members will usually go to. And it works fine.
3. CELCOM-Vodafone USB stick modem is smaller and more convenient
   Simply because it is more advance and easy to use, CELCOM’s USB stick SIM card is replaceable, while MAXIS USB modem is not.
4. Return of USB Modem to MAXIS
   Did you know, MAXIS wireless broadband service subscribers need to return the USB modem when they unsubscribe from its service? Subscribers are actually renting the device from MAXIS.
5. Too many complaints about MAXIS wireless broadband service
   If you google MAXIS wireless broadband, you will find a lot of negative comments about its service. Comments from other users may give you the true customers’ feedback.
6. Network Congestion
   There are too many MAXIS wireless broadband users. I would rather to pick a wireless network that “still not yet” overloaded.

However, the pricing, coverage and speed of service are the main concerns that one should consider most.

For information on CELCOM and MAXIS USB Modem, you may visit their website:
CELCOM-Vodafone USB stick: http://www.celcom.com.my/broadband/html/modem_bundle.html
MAXIS wireless broadband USB modem: http://www.maxis.com.my/personal/broadband/
broadband_wireless_usb_modem.asp

Updated 2009-09-22: Newer post ‘Latest MAXIS Wirelss Broadband Package’s Disadvantages‘ give you more information on the latest Maxis wireless broadband plan.

CELCOM Vodafone USB Stick

MAXIS USB Modem

Tags: CELCOM, MAXIS, USB Modem, Wireless Broadband

This entry was posted on Monday, March 23rd, 2009 at 10:43 pm and is filed under Computer Resources. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.